Tuesday , January 26 2021
Home / Politics / COVID 19: Key data behind the controversial tiers decision as MPs

COVID 19: Key data behind the controversial tiers decision as MPs

Political leaders across England are threatening to rebel against the government after being positioned in COVID-19 tiers they believe are unjust.

About 100 Conservative MPs (practically a 3rd of the party’s MPs) are concerned about the method the tiers were designated, environment secretary George Eustice told Sky News.

Boris Johnson has actually safeguarded positioning whole counties into higher tiers when they have large variations of coronavirus rates, health center admissions and deaths within them.

Live coronavirus updates on last day of England’s lockdown

The government used the brand-new Tiers 1, 2 and 3 to the biggest city government areas– counties, unitary authorities and city areas after its scientific advisers said it may make measures more effective. However, the choice has actually triggered anger in some districts. Political leaders and locals have stated it is unreasonable to put all locations in a greater tier since a different part of the county remains in an even worse COVID-19 scenario. Sky News takes a look at 4 locations to see why their tier allocation has actually ended up being controversial.

How were the tiers figured out?

SAGE, the federal government’s scientific advisory body, warned about “edge effects” – people moving between areas within a bigger region and for that reason making the spread of the infection most likely.

” Using steps to bigger locations, for example upper tier local authority (UTLA) rather than lower tier local authority, or area instead of UTLA, decreases the importance of ‘edge effects’ and might make procedures more effective,” the group encouraged.

The federal government has stated it will utilize the following criteria to determine which area remains in which tier: case rate in all age groups, case rate in the over 60s, the rate at which cases are rising or falling, positivity rate (portion of tests which come back positive), and the pressure on the NHS.

Kent and Medway

MPs in “The Garden of England” were irritated the entire county was positioned in Tier 3 when some locations have low COVID-19 rates.

Seven Conservative MPs composed to Health Secretary Matt Hancock, stating: “Kent is a very large county with unique locations within it, which is shown in the vast difference in the occurrence of COVID-19.”

Cases are rising in the entire county and the positivity rate – the number of individuals who are checked are positive – is over 5%. The World Health Organisation (WHO) says the figure needs to be under 5% to keep the epidemic under control.

Swale, in northeast Kent, has the highest positivity rate in England, together with Kirklees in West Yorkshire, and Stockton-on-Tees in County Durham.

The seaside district and close-by Thanet, also in Kent, have the greatest present infection rates in the country, but there are considerable distinctions with other locations in the very same county.


Cases are falling in the whole of Lancashire, however the positivity rate is above 5% in every local authority in the area. In some, like Pendle, Burnley and Hyndburn, there were 14 cases for every 100 tests performed in the location in the last week.

MPs and council leaders in Lancashire stated they are “furious” and “livid”, with Lancaster and Fleetwood MP Cat Smith stating her area is lower than all but one London district – which is in Tier 2.

Ribble Valley MP Nigel Evans, a Conservative, has written to the PM about his issues and is likely to rebel, while Paul Foster, the leader of South Ribble Council, has stated he would consider legal action if his area was positioned under the greatest tier.

Lancaster, like Tunbridge Wells in Kent, has one of the most affordable infection rates in a Tier 3 area. But the majority of Lancashire authorities have a high variety of COVID-19 cases.

Lancashire Rest of England Infection rates are likewise high or very high among the over 60s in Lancashire, as is the pressure on the NHS. Health centers in the north of England have been worst impacted, with increasing COVID-19 admissions increasing occupancy.

Lancashire Rest of England

Warwickshire plus Coventry and Solihull

Warwickshire was in Tier 1 prior to England’s second national lockdown and now has among the clearest departments within one county, with a north/south divide.

Stratford-on-Avon MP Nadhim Zahawi, who became the vaccine rollout minister over the weekend, stated he has actually spoken to Mr Hancock about the “extremely strong feelings” from constituents and is promoting Warwickshire to be considered apart from its neighbouring counties, and individually from Coventry and Solihull.

The leader of Stratford District Council, where rates are relatively low, stated it was a “surprise”, while managers of the town’s well-known Royal Shakespeare Business said they were “deeply dissatisfied”.

Regional council leaders, Conservative and Labour MPs and many business owners throughout the county have actually gotten in touch with the federal government to re-evaluate, stating it was simply Coventry and Solihull that the decision was made on.

Nuneaton and Bedworth’s weekly infection is three times that of Stratford-on-Avon. The number of COVID-19 cases in Shakespeare’s birthplace is presently among the most affordable in Tier 3.

Warwickshire Rest of England Leaving out Stratford-on-Avon, infection rates among the over 60s in Warwickshire are exceptionally high, putting significant pressure on the NHS.

Warwickshire Rest of England Cases are likewise decreasing much faster in the south of the county than in the north.

Warwickshire Rest of England

Devon plus Plymouth and Torbay

The debate is not almost counties being positioned in Tier 3 when they think they must remain in Tier 2, however also those who believe they should be in Tier 1.

The government stated it positioned Devon in Tier 2 due to the fact that “there is pressure at the Royal Devon and Exeter Health Center”, regardless of its infection rate being well below the national average.

MPs in the area have actually blamed this on “historical underfunding of healthcare in the South West”, especially in rural areas.

Lots of regional authorities in Devon, especially those on the border with Cornwall, have said it is unjust because their rates are comparable, or lower, than their southern neighbour, which is one of just 3 locations put in Tier 1.

All regional authorities in Devon have infection rates listed below the nationwide average, with South Hams and Teignbridge amongst the most affordable current rates in the country.

Devon, Plymouth and Torbay Rest of England The number of cases amongst the over 60s is also low in most of the county, other than in Exeter where it is higher than in lots of other Tier 2 areas.

Devon, Plymouth and Torbay Rest of England And while cases have actually been reducing in locations like South Hams, in recent weeks they have been increasing in Mid Devon more than in many other Tier 2 locations.

Devon, Plymouth and Torbay Rest of England

The federal government published an impact evaluation report of the steps ahead of MPs voting on the tiers, and stated it will evaluate the tiers on 16 December.

In spite of this, Mr Johnson now deals with a major disobedience with many backbench Tory MPs critical of the tier system.

Check Also

Nicola Sturgeon to seek ‘legal referendum’ on Scottish self-reliance

Nicola Sturgeon has accused Boris Johnson of being “frightened of democracy” and said she will …